Our Story: A Legacy of Local Fishing Knowledge in the Florida Keys

When you book a fishing trip in Marathon, Florida Keys with All Keys Charters, you’re not just going out on the water - you’re stepping into a rich, family tradition that spans generations. Captain Michael Schofield is a third-generation fishing captain and a proud Florida “Conch”, born and raised right here in the Keys.

Captain Mike’s deep-rooted connection to these waters began long before he took the helm. His family originally came to the Florida Keys from England and founded the historic Valhalla Beach Hotel, which once backed up to the now locally known Valhalla Sandbar. While the hotel is no longer there, the sandbar remains a favorite local landmark - a symbol of the Schofield family’s enduring legacy.

Mike’s father, a lifelong commercial fisherman, spent his career running lobster and crap traps throughout the Keys. From a young age, Mike was right there beside him, learning the ropes, managing thousands of traps, and developing a true respect for the ocean and the fishing industry. That early experience paved the way for a life on the water. He’s been fishing these waters for over 20 years and has held his captain’s license since 2012.

After a major storm impacted the family business, Captain Mike launched All Keys Charters with a mission: to share his passion for fishing and the Florida Keys with others. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or brand new to fishing, you’ll benefit from the expertise of a true local fishing guide in Marathon.

What sets All Keys Charters apart from the rest? It’s simple - experience, dedication, and local knowledge. “We spend almost 365 days a year fishing in these waters,” says Captain Mike. “We know the seasons, we know the hotspots, and as local guides, we’re personally invested in giving you the best possible experience on your fishing trip in Marathon, FL Keys.”

From reef and offshore adventures to shark and tarpon fishing or laid-back family outings, All Keys Charters offers a full range of guided trips tailored to your style. Captain Mike specializes in catching sailfish, kingfish mahi mahi, tuna, snapper, tarpon, wahoo, cobia, grouper, barracuda, redfish, bonefish and more - plus, he’s an expert when it comes to Florida’s fishing regulations and proper catch-and-release techniques.

With a new addition to the Schofield family, a fourth generation of Florida Keys fishermen is already in the making! So, when you choose All Keys Charters for your next fishing trip in Marathon, you’re not just booking a boat - you’re joining a family tradition built on generations of hard work, local pride, and a lifelong love of fishing!

Two Exceptional Boats for Every Style of Fishing

All Keys Charters gives you access to two top-tier fishing vessels, designed for both comfort and performance:

• 42-Foot Morgan
  Powered by twin 425HP Caterpillar engines and equipped with three oversized live wells, this boat offers serious power and space. It’s ideal for longer offshore adventures and big game fishing. With a full tower for sight fishing and optimal visibility, it’s built to perform in a variety of fishing conditions.

34-Foot SeaVee
Comfortable and versatile, the SeaVee is perfect for reef trips, tarpon runs, or family outings. Outfitted with top-of-the-line fishing gear and plenty of seating, this boat combines function and comfort for an easy day on the water.

Both boats feature well-maintained equipment, superior live well systems, full towers, and a 6-guest maximum to ensure plenty of space and a personalized experience. We are Coast Guard regulated and include a life raft, EPIRB, Garmin Electronics, VHS and Spot signal for WI-FI capabilities.

More Than a Boat Ride – A Fully-Guided, Local Fishing Experience

Unlike some other fishing charters in the Marathon FL or Key West areas, All Keys Charters only uses local captains and experienced deckhands. We live here. We fish here — almost every single day of the year. That local knowledge translates into real results, whether you’re hoping to catch mahi mahi, tuna, grouper, tarpon, or even scratch a sailfish off your bucket list.

Before each trip, we talk through your goals, the current conditions, and what’s biting to make sure we customize the perfect charter for you. We understand the seasonality of the fish and help guide you toward the best experience possible.